For months, I’ve been posting before-and-after photos of Eagle Scout service projects.
Gathering the photos is a highlight for me, and the series has been well-received by blog readers. However, some commenters have made an important point: Almost all of the projects spotlighted are construction-based.
You know what? They’re right. That’s an inherent flaw in our Extreme Makeovers series. It only includes physical projects — those that offer a permanent transformation to places like baseball diamonds, community parks and historic cemeteries.
I’m a fan of construction-based projects; my own involved constructing a wooden walkway and benches. But I know that many projects can’t be depicted with before-and-after photos.
Examples of these include planning and executing a blood drive, organizing a communitywide event, creating and distributing a safety pamphlet, and many more.
Shane Uribe’s Eagle project of the year
For proof that nonconstruction projects can make a huge difference, look to Shane Uribe. The California Eagle Scout won 2015’s Glenn A. and Melinda W. Adams National Eagle Scout Service Project of the Year Award.
You see, Shane spent his early years in several foster homes. He carried all of his belongings from place to place in a black trash bag.
Not wanting others to endure that same fate, he planned a duffel-bag drive. He filled 100 high-quality duffel bags with blankets, flashlights and stuffed animals. No trash bags for these kids.
His project was such a success that San Diego County decided to make it a permanent program. Now many more than 100 children will benefit from Shane’s project.
What the BSA says
Nowhere in the BSA’s guidance on Eagle Scout projects — not in the Guide to Advancement, not in the Eagle Scout Service Project Workbook — does it mandate that Eagle projects be construction-based or permanent.
The primary guidance is that a Life Scout must “plan, develop and give leadership to others in a service project helpful to any religious institution, any school or your community.”
That leaves an intentionally wide range of potential projects, and it includes projects that are construction-based and projects that aren’t.
While there are some rules — no projects that benefit the BSA, no fundraisers, no routine labor — there are more projects a Scout can do than ones they can’t.
Section 18.104.22.168 of the 2019 Guide to Advancement offers additional guidance. In fact, the Guide mentions blood drives specifically:
It is important not to categorically reject projects that, on the surface, may not seem to require enough planning and development. Consider, for example, a blood drive. Often rejected out of hand, this project, if done properly, could be acceptable. Few would question the beneficiary. Blood banks save lives — thousands of them: maybe yours, maybe that of a loved one. If the candidate proposes to use a set of “canned” instructions from the bank, implemented with no further planning, the planning effort would not meet the test.
On the other hand, there are councils in which Scouts and advancement committees have met with blood bank officials and worked out approaches that can comply. Typically these involve developing marketing plans and considering logistics. People successful in business know how important these skills are. Some blood banks will also set a minimum for blood collected as a measure of a successful plan. To provide another valuable lesson, they may require the candidate to keep at it until he’s met this goal.
A good test of any project is to evaluate its complexity. In the case of a blood drive, for example, elements of challenge and complexity can be added so there is a clear demonstration of planning, development, and leadership.
What I say
There’s no shortage of Eagle Scout project ideas. Some of the most interesting projects I read about are ones that aren’t on any of the lists that show up when you Google “Eagle project ideas.” As Scouters, I challenge you to turn the selfless act of a teenager — the desire to plan and complete an Eagle Scout project — into something they’ll remember for the rest of their life.
No matter what form it takes.
Sometimes that’ll be a construction-based project, with a shiny plaque screwed on, that will last for decades. The Eagle Scout will bring their own children there some day and tell them about the hours and hours of work put in there.
Sometimes that’ll be a collection-based project that left behind no physical evidence but still changed lives for the better.
And sometimes that’ll be a project that doesn’t fit into any category. With a little bit of guidance from you, those projects could be the best ones of all.